Is Swaminarayan the God? Simply put it, there are no ancient Hindu books that describe swamianrayan as a god or incarnation of any god. Swaminarayan sampraday is wealthy and rich, with political connection they are manipulating the minds of people and manipulating the Sanatan Hindu Dharma’s scriptures to show swaminarayan as a god. All Swaminarayan Sampraday shows 200 year old swaminarayan is superior to all Sanatan Dharma’s god and rest of the gods are inferior to Swaminarayan, including Brahma, Vishnu and Mahesh. On Social Media, there are numerous videos of Swaminarayan sampraday’s swami insulting Sanatan Dharma’s god. Swaminarayan Sampraday do not believe in goddess or Mataji; even though each and every one of them had to be born out of mother’s womb.
In Hinduism, there are 4 main yugs: Satya Yug, Treta Yug, Dwapar Yug and Kali Yug. Currently, humans are living in Kali Yug. In past, there were many people who called themselves god/bhagwan, and many will take birth and call themselves god, but one should understand the god. In this article, with some simple basic knowledge about Hinduism, I will prove why swaminarayan is not the god. Click here to read why BAPS is worst for Hinduism.
Is Swaminarayan Incarnation of Shri Krishna?
Swaminarayan followers believes that he was incarnation of Lord Krishna. Lord Krishna, himself, was an incarnation of Lord Vishnu. As per many different Puranas, Lord Vishnu’s Dashavatara as follows; Matsya, Kurma, Varaha, Narasimha, Vamana, Parashurama, Maryada Purshottam Shri RAM, Purn Purshottam Shri Krishna, Buddha and Kalki. Lord Vishnu is still to incarnate as a Kalki; Kalki will be the 10th and final incarnation of Vishnu, it has been foretold to appear at the end of the Kali Yug. Kalki will end Kali Yug and usher humanity into the new yuga.
- If swaminarayan is incarnation of Krishna, then he would have been ultimately 10th avatar of Lord Vishnu. Looking around current ongoing crisis in the world, anyone can clearly tell that we’re not leaving in Satya Yug. In contrast, for some reason, let’s just believe for a minute that swaminarayan was incarnation of Lord Krishna, then it would make “Dashavatara” story hoax. Either swaminarayan or Dashavatara story is false and fake, one of the story has to be hoax to prove my above theory. I lean towards swaminarayan being fake.
- On side note, during 14th century in West Bengal, India, “Chaitanya Mahaprabhu” spiritual teacher founded Gaudiya Vishanavism. Chaitanya Mahaprabhu followers believe that he was incarnation of Shri Krishna. If the same method is to follow, sarcastically speaking, Shri Krishna is due to born anytime now.
Swaminarayan books claim that Lord Hanuman came to swaminarayan, and Lord Hanuman expressed desired to worship swaminarayan for life time.
- When Hanuman Ji after finding the whereabouts of Sita ma, Hanuman Ji went to see Shri Ram at kishkindha. Hanuman Ji told the entire story of what happened in Lanka and how he found Sita ma. Shri Ram asked Hanuman ji for a boon, and Hanuman Ji only asked for following.
नाथ भगति अति सुखदायनी। देहु कृपा करि अनपायनी।।
सुनि प्रभु परम सरल कपि बानी। एवमस्तु तब कहेउ भवानी।।
Above slok is from Sunderkand (33.1), Hanuman Ji only and only ask for Prabhu Ram’s Bhakti.
Famous sloks from Bhagvat Geeta as follows
यदा यदा हि धर्मस्य ग्लानिर्भवति भारत ।
अभ्युत्थानमधर्मस्य तदात्मानं सृजाम्यहम् ॥४-७॥
परित्राणाय साधूनां विनाशाय च दुष्कृताम् ।
धर्मसंस्थापनार्थाय सम्भवामि युगे युगे॥४-८॥
Above sloks translate that “Whenever virtue subsides and wickedness prevails, I manifest Myself. To establish virtue, to destroy evil, to save the good I come from Yuga (age) to Yuga”. What adharm swaminarayan destroy? Swaminarayan had a very good relationship with Britishers. Jaliyawala bag kand and cruelty of Britishers are well-known. If swaminarayan is really the god, then why did he not destroy evil Britishers and stopped cruelty from all over the world?? Instead swaminaryan met Britishers more than 1 time, and supported Britishers, because of this millions of innocent people died all around the world. Supporting adharm also makes your adharmi. swaminarayan is nothing but adharmi.
Swaminarayan built temple for himself land given by Britishers. No god ever built temple for themselves. Ram and Krishna both were king, yet they didn’t build temple for themselves. Hindu has tendency to pray to anyone who sits in the temple. Swaminarayan was smart to figure it out, and built a temple for himself.
Mahatma Gandhi’s view on swaminarayan.
Prominent figure of the India’s independence, Mahatma Gandhi, also criticized Swaminarayan in his letter to Maganlal written on Thursday July 25th, 1918. In the letter, Mahatma Gandhi never addressed Swaminarayan as Bhagwan (God) and also put emphasis that Swaminarayan tradition is not true Vaishnava tradition. Gandhi Ji goes on to mention that Swaminarayan is all sentimentalism and not to compare Swaminarayan traditions with true Vaishnav tradition. Click on the below link for the full article on Mahatma Gandhi’s view on Swaminarayan
Even Mahatma Gandhi knew that swaminarayan practice are not true Vaishnava tradition, but current sampraday with hands full of greed made swaminarayan a god.
At times, hindu would involve in violence against Islam, but it is very sad to see that handful sects are dividing our own hindu religion, and made their own god supreme. Hinduism is considered the oldest religion in the world; but the oldest religion has been divided into Buddhism, Sikh, Jainism, and is now on path to divide further. Swaminarayan is also on the same path, we should unite all Hindus by following centuries old traditions and not by following any new modern world traditions.
Please spread this knowledge and educate others. Thank you.
Leave your comment/thoughts below.
Jay Shri Ram
If your intent is to educate people and guide them to right path you should also expose other things that are wrong like the following:
https://harekrishnacultexposed.blogspot.com/2018/01/racism-and-caste-bigotry-in-hare.html
LikeLike
Person can only expose on what he knows. I don’t know much about Iskcon, thus I cannot write anything about it.
LikeLike
This is clearly showes that how your snatana dharma teaches to disrespect other religions! If you don’t want to believe in lord swaminarayan that is ok but this article shows your poor mentality- this is what your dharma has taught you to put others down right?? Spread love stop hating others.
LikeLike
I’m so happy to see that you called your sampraday a religion. And this is what we desperately want!! Separate your religion from Sanatan Dharma.
For more, visit our facebook page to see how your swaminarayan religion is flourising with the help of Our Sanatan DHarma.
LikeLike
I’m not Swaminarayan follower but I respect him as Yogi, who did well in society and spread good knowledge, but after seeing Swaminarayan followers making him superior god, I started to hate them. Let him be what he was why are you making him superior god. He was one of thousands of Yo of yogis have been on earth who spread Santana Dharma’s knowledge and teach us best way to live life. I don’t believe that Swaminarayan followers spreading any good to Society but actually they are destroy our thousands of years legacy given by yogis and gods. I have experienced that if we say Jai Shree Krishna to some Swaminarayan follower they’ll reply you Jay Swaminarayan. They’re strictly believe in Swaminarayan only and not to believe in any other, which is never been said in our Santana Dharma. We have too many gods in our Santana Dharma and it allow us to believe in them and learn something from that. Krishna never said not to follow Rama or Shiva or any other god. Santana Dharma frees you to explore not to bound you while in opposite Swaminarayan follower bound you. I respect to a great Yogi Swaminarayan (not followers) and each and every Yogis have been on earth. Jay Swaminarayan, Jay shree Krishna.
LikeLike
Well Said.. That is what I learned from them. If they utter their swaminarayan’s say, I also say opposite and say Jay Shri Krishna.
LikeLike
“Jay Sri Krishna” is not the opposite of “Jay Swaminarayan”, no more than “Jay Sri Ram” is opposite. It is the same person. That’s the whole point.
Read Gita Upanishad, Chapter 10, please.
“Jay Sri Krishna”.
LikeLike
He was not even a genuine Yogi. This person, Ghanshyam Pande, is probably the greatest fraud because he declared himself Supreme God (Avatari). He misled people and put them on the wrong track. Genuine Yogi would never mislead people.
LikeLike
Dear Vijay,
I feel sad to read that you are hating people because they have a faith that is different from yours. The Supreme Being is unfathomable by human brain, because how can the finite comprehend the Infinite?
Bhagwan Sri Krishna says in Gita Upanishad, Ch.10, 42:
“But what need is there, Arjuna, for all this detailed knowledge? With a single fragment of Myself I pervade and support this entire universe.”
There are innumerable schools of religious and philosophical thought and practice in this world. I think a fundamental factor in maintaining a civilized society is to respect other people’s faith and beliefs, even if you not agree. ( Exception to this would if people are causing actual harm to others based on their beliefs.)
Swaminarayan Sampraday are advocating Ahimsa, Brahmacharya, Bhajan, Bhakti, Cleanliness, Truthfulness, and so many other aspects of high morality. How could you hate a group of people that are practicing and advocating these high moral principles, just because you cannot comprehend their philosophical point of view?
In Bhagavat Purān there is the story of Ajamil, who was saved from Hell by Vishnu-dutas, merely by calling out the name of his young son, who was named “Narayan”.
In Skanda Purān it is written that just by calling the name “Vaasudev” once, a person can be saved.
Hatred is a demonic attribute, and I implore you to renounce it.
Jay Sri Vāsudev, Jay Sri Krishna, Jay Sri Narayan, Jay Sri Ram, Jay Sri Buddha, Jay Sri Rshabhadev, Jay Sri Nrsinghadev, etc, etc,…. These are all the same Supreme Person walking on Earth to teach mankind and offer the chance and method for salvation.
LikeLike
ggovindbhai,
It is not about hating particular group. It is about whether Swaminarayan is God or not. He was not the only one who had preached good moral values to his followers. He had borrowed all those values from Vedic Scriptures and from previous saints, Acharyas etc. You don’t have to declare yourself “Sarvopari Bhagvan” to preach good moral values. It is good that followers of Swaminarayan Sampraday follow good morals and values but the problem is they are worshiping mere mortal human being as “Sarvopari Bhagvan”. He was not the God. He was not even genuine yogi. He was just human like other you and me. It is good to call him Social reformer, saint or Acharya but not the God. He fooled gullible and innocent Gujarati people. What will you get by worshiping human being as God? It defeats the purpose of upasana and worship. What will you get by praying to mere mortal human being?
LikeLike
Ooh about the FBI rade at nj mandir..
We have proof to prove innocent. We do VOLUNTEER WORK and they dont get paid. The sanstha provided everything to them but people like you get the chance to prove that BAPS is a scam and all of that but no..
Do you have any proof against this HUH HUH SHOW IT HUH
Eh i dont care if you dont approve this, as long as you see it, im fine bro
Ps. SHUTTTTT UPPPPP
LikeLike
lol.
Your bava tell you to not eat outside, instead they force you to eat in your BAPS Business restaurant. Therefore, you never had a Kadai Paneer; so you possibly don’t know the taste.
LikeLike
And if you think that BAPS is fake or lord swaminarayan is fraud than why didn’t any other sanstha came to help during the Russia & Ukraine war. Why did PM Narendra Modi called only Swamiji and asked them for a refugee camp near Poland border why didn’t ISKCON or any other sanstha came for help. You support ISCKON that is why you are having jealousy against BAPS that they help people all time and ISCKON doesn’t do it
LikeLike
if you think that BAPS is fake or lord swaminarayan is fraud than why didn’t any other sanstha came to help during the Russia & Ukraine war. How is this question related? Swami Narayan is True, and ultimate realization whereas swaminarayan is 200 year old made up god!!
LikeLike
This is really powerful revelation of an Ex BAPS Sadhu. This deserve place on your homepage. Don’t miss to here this.
LikeLike
I can’t open the link. May be something wrong??
Tell me the title and I will search it on YT.
LikeLike
search for “rahil patel baps” on Youtube
LikeLike
It is too long. Is there any specific timeframe you want me to look at?
LikeLike
Do you even care about listening to someone else’s perspective? Are you so busy that you cannot take an hr to listen to that video? Any you expect people to read though pages of your blogs? think about it.
LikeLike
https://nj1015.com/murphy-once-a-guest-there-horrified-by-slave-wage-accusations-at-robbinsville-temple/
LikeLike
the people gave info to the FBI, there is an article on it but i dont have the link so shut up
and I’m pretty sure you are not gonna approve this and if you do, thanks!
LikeLike
Lol. Work hard to find that proof. It is the name of BAPS on the line, else your BAPS and Mahant is considered Chor Here.
Any Proof after May 11 2021 and you will have my attention.
LikeLike
What about this.
Please post all post not just negative ones only.
https://www.organiser.org/Encyc/2021/5/13/Swaminarayan-Temple-USA-Labour-Caste-Discrimination-Charges-New-Jersey-Labour-Department-Initi.html
LikeLike
Lol kid there is something wrong with your thoughts process or you just want to ignore facts!!
I asked for anything after May 11. Read the article, there are refering things before May 11. May be your BAPS brainwashed you to ignore the simple facts.
Just FYI, there has been any update from FBI or NJ labor department on BAPS raid since May 11
LikeLike
Click to access 0001-KumarComplaint.pdf
LikeLike
https://midjersey.news/2021/05/11/baps-mandir-class-action-lawsuit-filed-on-behalf-of-workers-lured-from-india-paid-as-little-as-1-20-hr-stop-work-issued-by-njdol-as-federal-fbi-probe-continues/
LikeLike
What was the purpose of this? This is just a website. This wont change anything. Anything At all. This was
1. Waste of money
2. Stupid
3. Nonsence
4. FAKE
5. Waste of time
And instead of making articles on Swaminarayan, why not make articles on the story of the Mahabharat or the Ramayan. And these articles wont bother anyone.
LikeLike
Lol. I won’t change anything for any swaminarayan people. But I’m damn sure that this is bringing difference in people’s life.
Don’t believe me!! check our facebook in few days
LikeLike
Baps is money making machine.They show that they are doing charity in covid but actually they are collecting all around the world in name of services. If they are true should donate from old donations. But no they dont spend single penny out of donations received for making big temples .Instead they generate more money around the world by way of covid charity.Also lot of organizations help but Baps swaminarayan are master of marketing. They do 1% collect 5% and promote 100%.
LikeLike
true
LikeLike
Just FYI.
The owner of this blog is also asking donations separately so don’t waste time in this blog.
He doesn’t have any references but just uses same lines every time to justify his statement.
He thinks he is smarter and knowledgeable than pandits from Kashi and Mysore and Banaras and various other recognized organizations which has recognized BAPS. If he contradicts then god bless his ignorance.
Don’t waste time on this blog as it’s just scam to get extra money and just abusive language.
Also on reviews, please see the other 99 positive reviews instead of one negative.
LikeLike
Oh!! Thank you for pointing that out.. Which page has the donation button? I would love to remove that as I don’t need any donations any more!!
With the God Grace, I’m more than enough!!
LikeLike